How Do I Price My CPG Item? Understanding Cost, Margin, and Category Fit
We have a calculator that’s free to use!
Pricing is one of the most important decisions you will make as a CPG brand. It affects everything: your margins, your growth, and your survival. Get it wrong, and it doesn’t matter how great your product is. Too low, and you’re locked into a margin structure that collapses when distributors or retailers ask for more. You find yourself losing money on every sale, boxed into contracts that only get worse as you scale. Too high, and you’re dead on shelf next to lower-priced competitors. Either way, you lose.
Most founders start simple: cost of goods plus a margin. Then another margin for the distributor. Then another for the retailer. That gets you to a shelf price. But what if that price is too high for your category? Or too low to sustain your business? That’s where pricing gets complicated. And why you need to look deeper than just markup math. Because price isn’t just about margin; it’s about position.
Traditional Pricing: The COGS + Margin Trap
The standard model works like this:
Take your cost of goods (COGS).
Add 20% to 40% for your gross margin.
Add a distributor markup (often 15% to 35%).
Add a retailer margin (which could be 30% to 50%, depending on the store).
It’s fast, and it gives you a number. But that number might be wrong. This approach leaves out a lot—real costs that hit your bottom line. Storage. Freight. Distributor chargebacks. Retailer fees. Promo costs. Spoilage. Deductions. It’s all real money. It doesn’t show up in your spreadsheet at first, but it absolutely shows up in your bank account.
You don’t feel it when you’re selling at a farmer’s market. But you’ll feel it fast when you move into distribution and retail. Especially if you’ve priced yourself based on best-case assumptions. And once you’re locked in with retailers and distributors, changing that price is difficult—sometimes impossible.
Why Margins Vary So Much
Margins aren’t fixed. They vary by store, by product type, and by channel. Whole Foods, for example, tends to command higher margins—sometimes north of 45%—because they operate in a premium space with slower turns, more customer service, and higher labor and overhead costs. Publix sits more in the middle; a solid grocery chain with healthy margins but focused on everyday value. Winn-Dixie plays in the discount lane and may take a bit less—but don’t count on it being cheap.
Category matters too. Refrigerated hummus doesn’t get the same margin as shelf-stable popcorn. Frozen breakfast items don’t move like granola bars. Spoilage risk, handling requirements, and demand patterns all affect how much room retailers want in their cut. Slower-moving categories often have higher retail expectations; faster-turning categories may give you a bit more breathing room. If you’re in a category with low shelf velocity, you need to make sure the margins justify your presence.
Distributors add another layer. UNFI might take 15% on one category and 25% on another. KeHE may operate differently depending on region or category. Pod Foods is newer, tech-forward, and often leans lower on margin—but may charge other fees. Regional players have their own rules. Some include freight in their margin; others bill it separately. Some give you data; some don’t. Their markup depends on volume, efficiency, and how much effort it takes to move your product. And it’s not just the percentage—it’s the payment terms, the access, the services. It all adds up.
The Hidden Costs That Will Wreck Your Margins
Even if you think you’ve nailed your pricing, you probably haven’t captured everything. Most early-stage brands overlook:
Storage and inbound freight
Broken cases or spoilage
Distributor chargebacks
Promo costs that don’t perform
Retailer fees and deductions
E-commerce fulfillment and pick-pack charges
Broker commissions
Display and slotting fees
These aren’t edge cases. These are the rule. Every new account you land comes with hidden costs. Every promotion you run cuts deeper than you think. If you aren’t modeling these scenarios up front, you’re working off a fantasy margin that will never hit your P&L.
It’s not just about math; it’s about planning. Every cost you miss today becomes a profitability problem tomorrow. That’s how good products die in year two.
The Smarter Way: Pricing Built on Total Cost + Market Reality
We built a calculator to help you figure this out. One that forces you to enter everything—not just what you paid for your ingredients. Because your true cost to serve includes every step in the chain: raw goods, production, freight, storage, distribution, promo, retail programs, and e-commerce fees. If you’re not looking at that whole picture, your pricing is built on air.
But even that’s not enough. Pricing is also about category fit. It’s not enough to know your own costs; you have to know where your product fits in the aisle. If the category for your item has a top-end of $7.99 and you need $9.49 to survive, you’ve got a problem. Doesn’t matter if your product is the best thing ever made. Retail buyers won’t take it. Consumers won’t repurchase it. You can’t wish your way out of a category ceiling.
That’s why pricing and category analysis go hand-in-hand. Knowing your price target in the category is just as important as knowing the cost of your ingredients. You have to start with the category’s rules, then work backward into your cost structure. If your costs don’t work within the price ceiling, you either need to lower your costs or pick a different category. Hoping the market will bend to you is not a strategy.
Get It Right Early
You won’t have time to fix this later. Retailers don’t take kindly to pricing changes once you’re on the shelf. They expect consistency and professionalism. Your distributor won’t be thrilled either. Any attempt to renegotiate pricing will be met with friction—or worse, delisting. You might not get a second chance.
Price discipline is something you build from the beginning. It protects your margins, your brand, and your business model. It sets the tone for your growth strategy. It lets you forecast with confidence and avoid the constant scramble to make ends meet.
So don’t just guess. Model your costs. Pressure test your assumptions. Know your category. Talk to buyers. Get real-world data. And then use the pricing calculator to find a number that works for you, your trade partners, and your customer.
If you do this right, your price won’t just cover your costs. It will support growth. It will align with the market. And it will survive real-world conditions without crushing your margins.
Don’t build your business on fantasy math. Get the real numbers using The CPG Guy pricing calculator.